Can a Will be contested?

In South Africa, a will is a legal document that outlines a person’s wishes for the distribution of their assets and property after their death. It is important to have a will in place to ensure that your assets are distributed according to your wishes and to avoid potential disputes amongst your heirs. A will can also provide a peace of mind for you and for your loved ones, as it allows you to make arrangements for the care of minor children and dependants. However, wills may be contested on the basis that they do not accurately reflect the intentions of the deceased. When a will is successfully contested, it will be declared invalid, and the distribution of the estate will be governed by the rules of intestate succession. The laws that govern the contesting of wills are contained in the Wills Act of 1953 and the Administration of Estate Act of 1965.

South African laws recognise several grounds in which a will may be contested and this includes:

• Lack of mental capacity: this occurs if a person executing a will was not capable of understanding the nature and consequences of their actions, due to a mental disorder or illness such as dementia, depression or brain injuries. The will may be contested on the grounds that the person was not able to understand the implications of the will or that they were not able to make a rational decision.
• Undue influence: this occurs when someone uses coercion or manipulation to influence the decision of another person. In the context of making a will, this could include tactics such as threatening to withhold love or support if the person does not include certain beneficiaries in their will, using emotional manipulation such as guilt-tripping or playing on the person’s fear to influence their decision, and/or taking advantage of vulnerable person such as an elderly or ill person to gain control over their decisions.
• Fraud: a will may be contested on the grounds of fraud if it can be shown that the will was obtained through fraudulent means, such as forgery, misrepresentation or deception.
• Mistake: a will may be contested on the grounds of mistake if it can be shown that the person who made the will was mistaken about the identity of the beneficiary, the nature of the bequest or, the consequences of their action.

The contesting of wills is a complex and often emotional process. While there are several grounds on which a will may be contested in South Africa, It is important to keep in mind that these issues can be difficult to prove and may require the assistance of a legal professional. If you are considering contesting a will, it is recommended that you seek legal advice to ensure that your rights and interests are protected.